One-Off: The Norman Rockwell Nightmare - The Ann and Anthony Anastasi Story

One-Off: The Norman Rockwell Nightmare - The Ann and Anthony Anastasi Story

By Shane L. Waters, Wendy Cee, Gemma Hoskins

In this chilling one-off episode we peel back the layers of a story that distorts the idyllic image of American family life into a harrowing tale of jealousy, rage, and murder. This is the story of Ann and Anthony Anastasi, a couple whose life together began in a seemingly picture-perfect manner but descended into darkness.

Embark with us on a journey into the lives of Ann Marie Anastasi and Anthony Anastasi. Ann, born around 1973, was the epitome of a traditional young woman in Maryland, with a background shrouded in mystery. Anthony, born approximately in 1975, also remains an enigmatic figure from Maryland, whose life took a significant turn when he fell in love with and married Ann.

Our narrative picks up in the midst of their marriage. The Anastasis, having moved from Maryland to Sault Ste Marie, Michigan, for Anthony's role as a volunteer youth hockey coach, found themselves managing the complexities of a large family with five children. This episode delves into the depths of their relationship, exploring how a marriage that seemed to embody the American dream spiraled into a living nightmare.

Join us as we uncover the truth behind the facade of a happy family. We investigate the intricate details of their lives, the hidden tensions, and the shocking events that led to a tragic end. This episode of "Foul Play: Crime Series" promises to be a gripping exploration of the thin line between love and hate, and how quickly a seemingly perfect life can unravel into chaos. Tune in for a story that challenges the very notion of the 'perfect American family.'

Find us ⁠online.⁠

Support the show by joining our Black Label to support the show and unlock exclusive benefits. You can join on ⁠Patreon⁠ and ⁠Apple Podcast Premium⁠.

Follow us on ⁠Instagram⁠, ⁠Twitter⁠, and ⁠Facebook⁠. Join ⁠Shane's Facebook Group⁠.
Hosted by ⁠Shane Waters⁠. Listen to his other crime podcast ⁠Mystery Inc⁠, or his history podcast ⁠Hometown History⁠!

Our Sponsors:
* Check out Rosetta Stone and use my code TODAY for a great deal:
* This episode is sponsored by/brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at and get on your way to being your best self.

Support this podcast at —

Advertising Inquiries:

Privacy & Opt-Out:
Heart UK